Our Review
Movie: ELSINORE
Rating: R, Brief Graphic Nudity, Some Sexual Content, Language
Length: 1:51
Release Date: November 20, 2026
JEANNE: “To be or not to be” from Hamlet by William Shakespeare is one of the most quoted phrases from any play ever written. Shakespeare’s masterpiece about life and death also features a large brutalist castle named Elsinore, which screenwriter Stephen Beresford uses as the title of director Simon Stone’s new film, ELSINORE, about the accomplished British actor of stage and screen, Ian Charleson.
Played with a magnificent raw intensity by Andrew Scott, one of the finest actors working today, Charleson enjoys much success, most notably for his role as Eric Liddell in the Oscar-winning CHARIOTS OF FIRE. But his greatest desire is to play the titular role in Shakespeare’s Hamlet. In 1989, he is offered the part by Richard Eyre (Johnny Flynn), the director of the National Theatre in London.
As Charleson throws himself into preparing for this incredibly demanding role, he learns he is facing a crisis of his own. The AIDS epidemic is raging and because it is still the ‘80s and homophobia is rampant, Charleson is reluctant to make any statement regarding his sexuality. His friend and former collaborator, Derek Jarman (David Dawson), is particularly aggrieved with Charleson for refusing to go public.
As his illness progresses, Charleson seeks the help of Dr. Margaret Johnson (Olivia Colman), a leading researcher and physician who is a pioneer in HIV testing and ultimately saves countless lives during the epidemic. She tells him, “You shouldn’t do this, it will kill you.”, but for Charleson, not performing Hamlet is an even worse death sentence.
It is simply not possible to overstate the breadth and sheer brilliance of Scott’s performance. Though Hamlet is a tragedy --- and Scott did play the role in London’s West End --- Elsinore is anything but. Charleson in real life was a source of joy --- he was greatly loved by his friends and fellow actors. Scott conveys that ability to bring happiness and inspiration to others on a grand scale. He’s a marvel to watch.
And Colman is her usual fabulous self --- giving a realistic and powerful portrayal of this supremely dedicated doctor who selflessly saved so many. Other notables are Billie Piper, who stars as Charleson’s closest friend, Patsy Pollock, Matthew Beard, who plays another dear friend, Sean Mathias, and Peter Mullan as Charleson’s father, Jack.
Other ensemble actors include Juliet Stevenson, who plays Sylvia Sims, Charleson’s co-star in Hamlet --- she also knew Charleson in real life --- and Joe Locke and Luke Thompson. Locke portrays Nicholas, a fellow patient with Charleson --- and a huge fan. Thompson brings Georgie to life, another close friend of Charleson’s who becomes ill before Ian. Director Stone has a complete embarrassment of riches with his amazing cast.
ELSINORE is one of the finest films of 2026 and Scott gives the performance of a lifetime. Enhanced by a lovely, unobtrusive score by Stefan Gregory, it is a magical moviegoing experience.
OPINION: STRONG SEE IT NOW!
DAVID: ELSINORE is one of those films impossible to dismiss. It is based on the true story of Ian Charleson, a British actor who at the height of his career was suffering from a terminal illness but was determined to play Hamlet on stage while he was still physically able. One of Ian’s previous claims to fame was his role in the Best Picture winner CHARIOTS OF FIRE (1981).
Irish actor Andrew Scott gives a shattering performance playing Charleson, and he should be the front runner for the next Best Actor Award at the Oscars in 2027. His turn is reminiscent of past winners --- Daniel Day-Lewis comes to mind for MY LEFT FOOT. As a side note, Charleson replaces Day-Lewis as the titular character in Hamlet after he walked off in the middle of a performance. And Scott actually played Hamlet in 2017 at the Harold Pinter Theatre in London’s West End.
Scott shares plaudits with Olivia Colman who plays Dr. Margaret Johnson, an HIV specialist who counsels her patients on the best way to cope with their disease. Johnson pleads with Charleson to avoid unnecessary stress, such as performing Hamlet on stage with all its physicality. Does he listen? No. He implores her to attend one of his performances, but she is reticent.
ELSINORE takes place in 1989 London, and the film’s title comes from the name of the castle in Shakespeare’s play. This film is full of memorable moments. After Charleson gives his last performance, the other thespians in the National Theatre, called “Window Bangers”, pay tribute to him by banging on the windows all around the interior courtyard. Producers of the movie, which is directed by Australian Simon Stone with a screenplay by Stephen Beresford, had real actors play the “Window Bangers”. They either knew Ian outright or were previous recipients of the Ian Charleson Award established years ago. It’s an incredible sight.
Another emotional scene has Ian’s parents visiting him in the hospital. His mother Jean is portrayed by Georgie Glen of PBS “Call the Midwife”, and his father is played by Peter Mullan whose delayed reaction to his son’s plight is truly heartfelt. Juliet Stevenson plays Sylvia Sims, his co-star in Hamlet. Stevenson actually knew the real Charleson.
In yet another memorable sequence, patients under Dr. Johnson’s care, including Charleson, get together in their ward and do a very catchy dance number to the tune of “There’s No Business Like Show Business” sung by the incomparable Ethel Merman. And the music by composer Stefan Gregory is a character all its own. Often Gregory’s score is so loud it drowns out whatever Ian is spouting at the time. This is purposeful because it’s not what Ian is saying that’s important, it’s that he is actually able to say anything given his physical condition.
A special nod to Valerio Bonelli whose editing is quite special. He alternates quick shots of Ian gleefully rehearsing his role as Hamlet juxtaposed with shots of his off-stage life, past and present. It’s a remarkable job.
Thanks to the overall superb performances by the entire ensemble cast, especially Olivia Colman, and the indelible turn from Andrew Scott, ELSINORE is surely one of the best films of the year.
OPINION: STRONG SEE IT NOW!